Autumn 2005 Newsletter

PDF version (5 MB)

The Master’s Message

Since my last message to you, Summer has come and gone, and on my journeys between Hampshire and the Metropolis the colours of Autumn are already very much in evidence.

There have been a number of highlights in recent months, not least of which was my invitation to attend the Banquet of the Worshipful Company of Insurers as one of their official guests. This delightful event took place at the Mansion House and I am delighted to tell you that our own Banquet will take place there next year on Wednesday 25 th January. Please make a note in your diaries!

I also spent a delightful evening at the Ironmongers' Hall at the Worshipful Company of Management Consultants' Master's Dinner. One of their founder Liverymen, Denise Fellowes, is Head of Consultancy at the Centre for Charity Effectiveness at the Cass Business School of the City University. At our Spring Court Luncheon she addressed us on t he ways in which members of our Company might have the relevant skills which would be of valu e to the teaching, research and advisory services that they offer, and I know she would be very pleased to welcome new volunteers.

In May I attended a Service for the Sons of the Clergy at Saint Paul 's Cathedral and I shall be in attendance at another service there in October to celebrate the 400 th Anniversary of the granting of the Royal Charter to the Worshipful Company of Butchers. We shall be celebrating our 25 th year of the Livery in March next year and we will be holding our own celebrations to mark this equally prestigious event.

Our Spring Livery Dinner in June was held in the wonderful hall belonging to the Apothecaries, of which I am a Yeoman, and we were very fortunate indeed to have Sir Oliver Popplewell as our speaker. I had already had the good fortune to hear him speak at the launch of his autobiography entitled “Benchmark—Life, Laughter and the Law”, and knew he would not disappoint us!

I am a little disappointed that so few of the Company attend these important occasions, and I would welcome some feedback from members to help the Court to identify which events may prove more popular in future.

The election of Sheriffs for the forthcoming year was held on 24 th June and commenced with b reakfast on HQS Wellington, the home of the Honourable Company of Master Mariners. I attended the election of the Lord Mayor on 29 th September, and for the future I would urge all Liverymen to attend and exercise their right to vote at this most impressive ceremony.

This year saw the first trip abroad for the Company when twenty seven of us set off for a most informative and highly successful trip to Burgundy. We were blessed with continuous sunshine and an equally continuous flow of wine. Our lunchtime tasting and picnic in the vineyard at the Domaine Jacob, so ably organized by my good friends Jean-Michel and Christine, was truly memorable! My thanks also go to John Owen-Ward who master minded the entire operation with his usual quiet efficiency.

The Master presenting John Owen-Ward with a token of appreciation during the Company's Trip to Burgundy

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The annual Church Service was held at Saint Mary Aldermary on 12 July this year, and was followed by a river trip on an evening which must have been one of the warmest of the year. Again it was a great pity that so few members of the Company supported such a well organized and enjoyable event.

There are still a number of functions for me to attend and also a Company visit to the Magic Circle s cheduled for Tuesday October 4 th. This will be followed by the Installation Dinner at Vintners Hall on Tuesday 25 th October.

In conclusion may I say how much I have enjoyed my year as Master. I am indeed honoured to have been able to represent the Company at so many prestigious events, to have had the opportunity to meet so many interesting people and hopefully to have spread the arbitral word.

It has been a great privilege.

Burgundy Weekend

Early on Thursday 9 th June 27 members of the Company and their friends flew from Heathrow to Lyons where we arrived to a warm sunny welcome. We were then driven in our luxury coach to Le Hameau restaurant in Romaneche Thorins where we were to experience our first insight into the splendid hospitality which our Master and John Owen-Ward had arranged for us.

A three course lunch was combined with an introduction to wine tasting followed by a sampling of Beaujolais wines from the well known producer Georges Duboeuf. Although many of the party we already well versed in the joys of wine tasting for us lesser mortals this early tuition proved invaluable.

The Hotel de Baranges in Buxy was our base for the next few days and turned out to be a 19 th Century chateau with elegant rooms and a lovely garden, well located for a trip into the village to explore the ancient buildings and local shops. You can tell that the writer is female! Dinner was in a delightful old restaurant Aux Annees Vins where we had an excellent meal which commenced with a delicious potato and smoked salmon terrine.

Friday dawned dry and sunny for our visit to Francois Freres Tonnellerie, a barrel-making factory in Saint Romain. This taught us the importance of selecting carefully chosen French oak with the correct grain, precision cut and weathered for several years. A circle of staves is placed over a fire to bend the wood and the rings are then placed to maintain the shape and the barrel internally “toasted” to make it watertight. I imagine their working practices fell somewhat short of our own Health and Safety standards as was evidenced by the number of missing digits! They don't normally “do” tours and we were grateful to Ann that her personal contacts enabled us to participate in such an interesting visit.

We then continued to Domaine Lucien Jacob at Echevronne, a small village to the north west of Beaune where Jean-Michel gave us a most knowledgeable tasting of the wines in his cellar and ably answered some very erudite questions! We then emerged into the sunlight for a three course picnic in a dappled clearing overlooking the Hautes-Cotes de Beaune. The setting could not have been more idyllic nor the weather more superb. The drive back took us through Mersault and Givry, amongst other famous names and it was magical to drive past so many villages which previously had only been labels on bottles to me!

In the evening we returned to Mercurey (another famous name) for dinner at the Val d'Or and tasted on e of the best wines we had during the trip — a 1999 Les Coteaux des Moines from Bouchard Pere et Fils chosen for us by John Owen-Ward.

Saturday took us back to Beaune and a visit to the famous Hospices, built in 1443 by Nicholas Rolin, Duke of Burgundy as a hospital for the poor and funded by also offering beds to the wealthy in exchange for bequests of land! This means that it is well funded by local vineyards to this day. It has a beautiful central courtyard surrounded by the w on derful multicoloured tiled roofs that have become a hallmark of the regi on and it is c on sidered to be a jewel of medieval architecture. Every Autumn it hosts the aucti on of wines which sets the prices for the ensuing year.

After lunch at Le Cellier de la Cabiote close by and yet another superb tasting of six whites and six reds we fell back out into the street just in time for some retail therapy at the Beaune Saturday market. There were some very tempting goods on offer but we thought it a little antisocial to transport garlic and rather smelly cheeses all the way back to England.

Members enjoying their trip to Burgundy

 

 

 

 

 

 

Our faithful coach took us back to Buxy and after a quick turn around and a glass of Montagny Premier Cru on the terrace we continued on to a charming canal side restaurant in Remigny where we had perhaps our best meal. A starter of home smoked salmon was followed by a delicious steak and local strawberries, all washed down with the usual excellent burgundies. John was delighted when Ann expressed her thanks to him for arranging the trip so expertly and she presented him with a jereboam of Gevrey Chambertin on the strict understanding that he would carry it back home himself! Past Master Bill Armstrong then thanked Ann on behalf of the party for deciding to take us to Burgundy.

A barrel is started.... and finished at Saint Roman

Time for a chat... and a well-earned lunch

So Sunday finally arrived and we sadly put our bags back on the coach to return to Lyons via the scenic route through Beaujolais leaving pinot noir country and returning again to the land of the gamay. We stopped for lunch at the Cafe des Sport at Fleurie, after which we still had plenty of time to sample and buy innumerable different beaujolais at the local Co-operative. We were fortunate that it was open on a Sunday afternoon! We then continued on our way through Moulin a Vent, Saint Amour, Chiroubles and another tour of Beaujolais labels this time, finally to return to the airport to find that the plane was delayed. So we did have one technical hitch but it in no way detracted from what had been the most informative and convivial trip I have experienced in a very long time.

Our thanks go to Ann and John.

Jenny Jones

Nautical Notes

The Cowes Sail and Power Race for the City Livery Companies was held over the weekend of 20/22 nd May this year at the world-famous centre for yacht racing on the Isle of Wight.

The Arbitrators' Company was represented by Pelagic Rainbow, a Moody 36, owned and skippered by Past Master Michael Wilkey, who is also a Rear-Commodore of the City Livery Yacht Club.

Some seventeen yachts vied with each other to arrive first at the start line, with the course being signalled by code from the shore some minutes prior to the start gun. It was essential for the sequence of buoys to be plotted accurately, with particular attention to the direction in which they were required to be rounded.

In rising winds and with a heavy sea breaking over the decks, skippers and crew pushed their boats to the limit, whilst also having to calculate whether to use engine power when going against the wind, all of which was within the rules of the race!

Boats risked their sails and rigging in order to gain an advantage, and after several hours of hard racing, the wet and tired crews took the finish line gun and headed for their moorings. More than 160 members and guests had a wonderful Gala Dinner at the Royal Corinthian Yacht Club later that evening. It was a long wait for the winner to be announced, especially as we thought we were in with a chance. And so we were, for the winning Livery Company boat on handicap was Pelagic Rainbow of the Arbitrators, followed by boats of the Lightmongers, the Innholders and the Guild of Freemen.

It was a great pleasure and privilege to be a member of the Arbitrators' winning crew.

Liveryman Donald Vincent-Gill

(Right) Past Master Michael Wilkey holding the Lord Mayor's Cup for 1st place, with first mate Mrs Susan Wilkey holding the Champion Cup, presented to the winning Livery Company, which this year was the Arbitrators'.

Spring Livery Dinner

The Master of the Actuaries' Company, Mr Alan Frost, with Dame Elizabeth Gloster and Sir Oliver Popplewell

Assistant John Rushton, Mrs Jenny Rushton, Mrs Isobel Crease and Liveryman Bob Crease

Mr Alexander Sturge, Mrs Hilary Goodridge, Liveryman Michael Goodridge MBE and Mrs Ros Sturge

Mrs Margaret Bickford-Smith QC, Actuaries' Clerk Mr Michael Turner and Assistant Kim Franklin

The Clerk Mrs Gaye Duffy with Freeman John Ansell and Assistant Barry Rose

Assistant Harold Crowter with Mr Barry Bridgeman, Chief Clerk of Keating’s Chambers

Management Consultants’ Clerk, Lt Col Dennis Hall, with The Master Management Consultant, Mr Alan Duguid

The Master Farmer, Mr Nicholas Fisk, with his Clerk, Miss Margaret Winter

Ms Jenny Taylor and Assistant Tony Scott

Ms Deborah Ruff and Liveryman Dr Mark Hoyle

Ms Catherine Bennett and Liveryman Peter Knight

 

Company database and list of members

At the end of June this year, the Clerk circulated members concerning the Company's intention to produce an updated List of Members this autumn, and to advise each member of their personal information that the Clerk currently holds on file. A tear off slip was provided to enable members whose details on file were out of date to advise the Clerk of any amendments she should make before sending the forthcoming List of Members for printing. There was no need to return the tear off slip if the details held on file were correct.

This article is to remind members that the closing date for the return of the tear off slips was 30 September 2005, so any member needing to send amendments to the Clerk should do so without delay (see the Clerk's contact details on the back cover of this Newsletter).

Members are also advised that under the Data Protection Act they are entitled to decline to have their personal contact details published in the List of Members. However, the Company takes the view that it is up to members to make that election if they do not wish their contact details to appear. The List of Members is only distributed to other members of the Worshipful Company, but if any members do not wish their contact details to be circulated within that select group, they should contact the Clerk without delay to make those wishes known to her. Otherwise, it will be assumed that members have no objection to your contact details being made known to other members of the Company in the forthcoming List of Members.

In December 2004 the Clerk circulated a note requesting members to give their permission for other members to be able to look up their contact details on the website. This is a very useful facility, and members who have not already done so are urged to give their permission by registering at the Members' Area of the website (at www.arbitratorscompany.org), accessing their own details, and giving permission by altering the entry in the first box of their Profile. This gives 4 drop-down options, which could not be simpler.

Members who have registered on the website may also check the details that the Clerk currently holds for them, and alter those details on-line if need be, without disturbing the Clerk. They can however only look up the contact details of those members who have consented to making themselves visible to other members of the Company on our website. So if you have not already given your permission, now is probably a very good time to do so.

 

Charitable Trust Prizewinner

The Master presenting Charitable Trust Prize Winner Miss Anna Bicarregui with her prize at the Spring Livery Dinner, supported by The Junior Warden Dr Donald Valentine, Charitable Trust Chairman John Rushton and The Senior Warden Michael Stephens

Charitable Trust News

Hackney Carriage Drivers' Tour

If you couldn't get a cab in the City on the morning of Friday 23 rd September it was probably because they were all at Canary Wharf, waiting to go off to Disneyland Paris. The Childrens' Magical Taxi Tour is an annual event organised by the Worshipful Company of Hackney Carriage Drivers and this year involved more than 100 black cabs taking disadvantaged and terminally-ill children on the trip of a lifetime.

The Company, through the auspices of the Second Trust, sponsored a cab. Pictured below are its driver Mick – who had made the trip before - and his passengers Hassiba (8) and Mohammed (6), together with their mother. You can see above how the cab looked in all its glory, with the Company's arms proudly displayed on the driver's door.

After a breakfast reception at Cabot Hall for all concerned and after hearing the good wishes of the Lord Mayor (who proved himself capable of wearing many hats!) the convoy departed at 8.30 a.m., accompanied by volunteers from the emergency services. On this occasion they included representatives from the Paris gendarmerie and the AA.

The Senior Warden, Michael Stephens, represented the Company on the day.

King Edward's School, Whitley

King Edward's School Witley, near Godalming, Surrey, is very much associated with the City of London. It was founded in 1533 by Royal Charter of Edward VI, who granted the Palace of Bridewell to the Lord Mayor and Commonalty for the purpose of providing care and education, particularly in crafts, for destitute children. The school moved to Witley in 1867 and has been co-educational since 1952.

The school is supported by the Bridewell Foundation and its many benefactors included a large number of the City livery companies. It prides itself on being “A Traditional School with a modern outlook”. About a quarter of the pupils are in receipt of funding to some degree and about half of the school is made up of children drawn from the inner London boroughs. Pupils are aged between 11 and 18.

(Above) The Senior Warden with the Registrar, Mrs Pat Snelling, and the Headmaster, Mr P Ferr Fulton-Peebles
(Below) The Senior Warden with Headgirl, Fiona Gaw.

I was invited to tour the school and meet with the Headmaster and other members of staff. I was shown around by the Head Girl, Fiona Gaw, and was very impressed by the quality and breadth of the school's facilities. The school follows both “A” level and International Baccalaureate programmes. Many of the sixth form students go on to higher education.

The Company's Second Trust has been able to provide financial support to a student of the school so as to allow her to continue with her studies in circumstances where she would otherwise have had to withdraw for lack of funds.

I had a very useful discussion with the Headmaster, the Registrar and Director of Development and will be reporting to the Trust about how further assistance can be given to benefit pupils in the future.

Michael Stephens, Senior Warden

Lord Donaldson of Lymington

Many of our members and others who were involved with commercial arbitration in the 1970s -1980s will have been sad to learn of the death of Lord Donaldson, and some may feel that the obituary in the Times did not do him full justice.

After serving in the Royal Corps of Signals during the War, he left the army as a lieutenant colonel, and was called to the Bar in 1946, having previously obtained a degree in law at Cambridge University. He specialised in Maritime Law.

In 1966 he was made a judge of the Queen's Bench Division; the youngest High Court Judge for many years. In 1971 he became President of the National Industrial Relations Court, which was not a popular institution, particularly with Trades Unions, and in spite of his courtesy and fairness, his reputation suffered as a result of this appointment. The NIRC was abolished in 1974, and Sir John Donaldson became Chairman of the Commercial Court (Queen's Bench Division) and of the Commercial Court Committee.

Sir John dealt with a large number of commercial disputes, mostly international, which gave rise to arbitrations and “stated cases” for the High Court. He developed a great interest in commercial contracts and trading practices. He was a most courteous and efficient Chairman of the Commercial Court Committee, and when the Grain and Feed Trade Association (GAFTA) came to revise its arbitration rules, Sir John came to meet its Rules Committee and gave them advice and guidance on legal and procedural points that lay arbitrators may find difficult. We were delighted when he accepted Honorary Membership of GAFTA. He remained a good friend, always approachable and helpful.

In 1982 GAFTA had the responsibility of hosting the European Commodities Exchanges Annual Trading Day, which is known as the European Bourse, in London. This was attended by about 2,000 traders from all over Europe and beyond. The opening ceremony was arranged in the newly opened Barbican Centre, and the Minister of Agriculture, The Rt. Hon. Mr Peter Walker MP, agreed to come and give the keynote address, but at a very late stage he had to withdraw because of ministerial commitments. Thus we had to find a suitable speaker at very short notice. I asked Sir John, who was by then Master of the Rolls, if he could come, and he readily agreed. While the platform party were in the green room waiting to go on stage, Sir John looked up from his notes, and said with a positive twinkle in his eye, “ Can I take it that someone will be making it clear that I am not Peter Walker?

Sir John's wife, Lady Donaldson, was Lord Mayor of London in 1983, and she was London 's first Lady Lord Mayor. Sir John was a great support during her successful Mayoralty, and she gave her unobtrusive support to the Founder Members of The Worshipful Company of Arbitrators. Sir John was made a Lord in 1988.

Past Master James Mackie

Past Master Frank E Rehder, CVO

Past Master Rehder's niece Angela, Mrs Keith Potter, has very kindly given permission for us to reproduce below her tribute to her uncle at his funeral last June.

“My uncle was born in Weybridge, Surrey on 4 August 1918. He was educated at Charterhouse & Corpus Christi, Oxford. In addition to his degree, he won a ½ Blue for shooting.

During the Second World War he became a Captain in the Royal Artillery. He fought, and was wounded, in Italy.

He began his law career in Newcastle, and later joined his father's firm, Rehder & Higgs, in London. The company later became Sinclair, Roche & Temperley, and this is where Frank remained for the rest of his career.

He became a leading figure in the field of maritime arbitration, eventually becoming Master of the Worshipful Company of Arbitrators. His private clients included the Duke of Edinburgh, and for this service he was made CVO.

He had a very happy childhood, his life greatly influenced by his two doting elder sisters, Margaret and my mother, Dorsy, both of whom he was able to repay with much help and wise advice in later years – even though they never forgave him for beating them so thoroughly at croquet! They used to gang up against him, and make him play left handed, but he would still win easily! His childhood also saw the beginning of a lifelong passion for trains. At Dulwich, the Golden Arrow used to run past the end of the garden and my mother would describe how he would always race down to watch it. Later, on holiday in Switzerland, he always went to Kandersteg. Every evening, after dinner, he would set off smartly to the railway station for a spot of (punctual) train spotting, with the rest of us dragging along behind.

He remained devoted to his family throughout his life, and gave all of us guidance and encouragement whenever he could. He also helped many others in less fortunate circumstances than his own. He was deeply interested in young peoples' education, because he believed a strong family and a good education vitally important building blocks for a happy and successful career, and as Joyce, John, Jan and Jane, and no doubt everyone else here can confirm, a friendship with Frank was a loyal and dependable friendship for life.

At Chichester, Frank was able to pursue his other great interest, which was gardening. His garden gave him much solace and enjoyment, and although his dahlias there were never to match the blaze of glory he achieved at Dulwich, he was apt to win prizes at the local flower show for his fruit and vegetables; sometimes as much as 25p! This gave him great satisfaction, and provided the ingredients for his famous home-made jam. At Christmas, he would assemble grand nephews and nieces on the floor around his chair, and with suitable ceremony gravely distribute jars of his jam into the expectant hands.

He will be greatly missed by us all, but if there are arbitrations in the Highest Court of All, they now have just the man to work tirelessly to find a fair and reasonable solution to any dispute.

Frank was the rock and head of our family, and it is now time to say good-bye to this kind and gentle man whom I loved. I will miss him.”

Angela Potter

Admissions to the Livery

Liveryman Karl Davies, Chief Executive of the City Disputes Panel and member of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators, who was admitted to the Livery on 27 April 2005.

 

 

 

Liveryman Matthew Molloy DipArb, FRICS, FCIOB, FCIArb, a Chartered Quantity Surveyor and Accredited Mediator with an MSc in Construction Management, who became a Liveryman on 27 April 2005.

 

 

Admissions to the Freedom

Freeman James Daniels, a Consultant Petroleum Engineer in oilfield project management, an International Arbitration Tribunal Chairman and Member, insurance claims loss adjuster and mediator, who was admitted to the Freedom on 27 April 2005.

 

 

 

Freeman Ike Ehiribe, a Barrister and practising Arbitrator, a part-time lecturer of International and Comparative Commercial Arbitration on the University of London External LLM Programme, and a member of the Panel of Assessors of the Chartered Institute of Commercial Mediators, who became a Freeman on 27 April 2005.

 

 

Freeman Chris Pedersen MCIArb, FRICS, a QS with a Masters' degree in Arbitration and ADR Practice from Kingston University, a Contracts Manager, an Apprentice to the Company and a member of the Oil and Gas Branch of the Arbitration Club, who was admitted to the Freedom on 27 April 2005.

 

 

Apprentices

Apprentice Grant Elliott, a Fellow of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators who is currently undergoing Pupillage training to become a Chartered Arbitrator

 

 

Diary of Events

29 September: Election of Lord Mayor at Guildhall
4 October: Visit to Magic Circle and Supper
25 October: Court meeting, Common Hall and Installation Dinner at Vintners’ Hall
12 November: The Lord Mayor's Show
25 January: Annual Banquet, Mansion House

Events Committee Vacancies

Membership of the Events Committee is a very rewarding way of contributing to the social activities of the Worshipful Company. Since its inception, the Company has very successfully provided a broad range of social and other events for the enjoyment of members. These events have in the main been organised by members on a voluntary basis, which boosts the vitality of the Company, and gives those who do it a well-deserved sense of achievement. To maintain this tradition, we are currently seeking further volunteers to ensure there are sufficient willing hands available to make light work of this important aspect of the Company's activities.

The major set-piece Dinners and the like are organised by the Master and the Clerk, and the remaining less formal events are organised by an Events Committee, chaired by Court Assistant Hew Dundas.  Hew is very keen to expand the membership of the Events Committee, to enable it to provide more, and more varied, events for our enjoyment throughout the year, and to ease the commitments of the too few existing committee members, who are all busy professi on als.

YOU could make a valuable contribution to the Company by joining the Events Committee, and will undoubtedly enjoy the social contacts involved in assisting to organise one, possibly two, events per year. 

So if you think you would like to get involved and make a very welcome contribution, please contact Hew on 07778-406457 or by e-mail on dundas.energy@btinternet.com.

 

Back to the top